U.S. Equities: Value Rebounds, but the Rotation Isn’t Defensive – Yet
Over the past 90 days, the growth and value segments of the U.S. equity market have delivered almost identical returns: +13.6% for growth and +13.7% for value. Judging solely by this comparison, one might conclude that nothing meaningful has happened between the two investment styles. That conclusion, however, would be misleading.
The identical end result masks two sequential but opposite moves. During the first part of the period—roughly through the end of April—growth outperformed by a wide margin, driving the ratio between the two indices up by more than six points in just one month. It then stalled. Over the past 60 days, growth has returned -0.1%, while value has gained +6.2%, causing the ratio to give back almost six points. This is not a case of rotation failing to materialize; rather, it is a rotation that emerged only after a false start.
The key question raised by this rotation is not whether it is taking place—the data clearly confirm that it is—but what kind of rotation it represents. When capital flows shift toward value, they generally do so for one of two fundamentally different reasons. The first is a flight to safety: investors reduce risk exposure and move into stable, high-dividend sectors with limited sensitivity to the economic cycle. The second is a bet on economic expansion: the market begins to favor companies more closely tied to the real economy over technology stocks whose performance has been largely driven by multiple expansion. These two interpretations imply very different conclusions about what is happening today and what investors should expect in the weeks ahead. Determining which one is correct requires looking beyond value as a broad style and examining which value sectors are actually leading the advance.
The most direct test comes from the sectors that have historically led defensive rotations: Consumer Staples and Utilities.
🔒 Subscriber-only content. Activate 14-day free trial or Login here
